For a spacelike path, you would use the $+$ under the square root and interpret the $s$ as the proper length separating the points. & Bulashenko, O. Anisotropic metamaterial as an analogue of a black hole. {\left|E\right|}^{2}\)); however, only the electric field amplitude is shown here for better visualization of both small and large amplitude features. Express 21, 19082–19090 (2013). ξ s It omits the spatial translations (three dimensions) and boosts (three dimensions). 4. At r = 0 the curvature becomes infinite, indicating the presence of a singularity. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Pires, D. G., Rocha, J. C. A. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. ^ T Specifically, we investigate the number of annuli needed to sufficiently mimic the true scalar-index profile and explore the impact of imperfect construction and experimental error on the deviation of the ray trajectory from the geodesic. This can be seen immediately by noting that initially counter-rotating geodesics (those with \(\hat{\ell }\) of opposite sign to \(\hat{a}\)) must turn around and become co-rotating before crossing into the ergosphere; such a reversal of the sign of \(\frac{{\rm{d}}\phi }{{\rm{d}}\rho }\) is not possible with a finite (and positive) scalar index. Science 312, 1777–1780 (2006). Lett. Regarding ds=0 being a path followed by massless particles such as light, if i search numerically for very small sequences of ds=0 steps from a starting point, will it end up being a geodesic path followed by light? Several optical Kerr–Newman black holes are also simulated, with profiles n(P) in Fig. B 83, 195424 (2011). but the transformation that converts these coordinates to Cartesian ones is singular. Phys. This makes total sense. Box 7.3aising and Lowering Indices in Cartesian Coordinates R 83 Box 7.4he Tensor Equation for Conservation of Charge T 84. . Leonhardt, U. It is important to note here that this geometry was chosen for simplicity in the finite-difference frequency-domain simulations of the next section, in which dimensions are constrained by the wavelength. Setting n = 1 at P → ∞ in Eq. First, we reiterate that Eq. We choose a specific trajectory with impact parameter \(\hat{b}_\infty =3\) to connect with the FDFD simulations of the previous section. 6b as a function of radius P = R/M. The minimum gradient scale length of the scalar-index profiles in Figs. By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. In table above, some shorthand has been introduced for brevity. Most trajectories follow the geodesic closely, within ΔΦ ≤ 2∘, for P > 3; however, within P < 3, ΔΦ grows rapidly. (14) and (23). Here, the optical black hole could be modeled completely to the horizon at Rh = 2.5 μm. Therefore, though the horizon is at Ph = 1, the system is modeled with innermost radius P = 1.4. Specifically, the behavior of light in a curved spacetime background described by metric gμν is reproduced in flat space within an impedance-matched bianisotropic medium with permittivity ϵij, permeability μij, and magnetoelectric coupling αi given by, where γij is the three-dimensional metric tensor of the real space coordinate system in which we construct the medium, onto which we map the spatial components gij. 2 53, this choice of identification between the spacetime geometry and the electromagnetic analogue, elaborated first in ref. Lett. & Hwang, E. Experimental modeling of cosmological inflation with metamaterials. It is possible for a particle to have a constant value of r between rs and 1.5rs, but only if some force acts to keep it there. For timelike paths, proper time is a common choice. This is the principle of general covariance. The scalar index for an optical Kerr–Newman black hole is again given by. This results because the impact parameter is nearly equal to that at which light becomes trapped, \(\hat{b}_\infty =3\sqrt{3}\approx 5.2\). The innermost modeled radius varies for each simulation, depending on whether n(P) diverges outside of the horizon. Synge, J. L. "Model universes with spherical symmetry." For ordinary stars and planets this is always the case. J. Opt. Thompson, R. T. & Frauendiener, J. Dielectric analog space-times. Kerr Metric in Cartesian Coordinates Ask Question Asked 2 years, 10 months ago Modified 2 years, 10 months ago Viewed 516 times 2 I have checked online and the Kerr metric never seems to be given in Cartesian coordinates (although there is a conversion factor from Cartesian to Boyer-Lindquist coordinates). The aim of this section is to find a global system of harmonic coordinates for the complete Schwarzschild model, which must be asymptotically Cartesian and such that the components of the metric are C1 at the boundary Σ : r = r0. The Schwarzschild metric describes the spacetime geometry of a static, uncharged black hole of mass M, and is given in dimensionless Schwarzschild coordinates \(\hat{s},\hat{t},\rho ,\theta ,\phi . 99, 063903 (2007). Correspondence to Analogue spacetimes1,2,14,15,16,17,18,19 use optical materials to implement coordinate transformations between a physical space and a virtual “electromagnetic space”, via the formal equivalence between Maxwell’s equations in curved spacetime and those in flat spacetime within a corresponding bianisotropic medium19,20,21,22,23. For future questions, you can refer to. A 380, 1–8 (2016). I was worried about taking absolute value before the square root to get rid of negative quantities, but this is standard procedure for computing ds, right? You can then press tab to accept, or type the whole thing out yourself. {\displaystyle R} The finite-difference frequency-domain solver used in this work is available at https://github.com/wsshin/maxwellfdfd. Article Here, we derive Eq. . The ray trajectories (Fig. ( However, as there is no analytic solution to the wave equation for the system under consideration, the pursuit of a more appropriate metric is left to future work. Box 5.2roof of the Metric Transformation Law P 59 Box 5.3 A 2D Example: . The Kerr–Newman metric describes the spacetime geometry surrounding a black hole of mass M, angular momentum per unit mass a = J/M, electric charge Q, and magnetic charge Qm. 5 for \(\hat{b}_\infty \in [0,5]\) and the number of annuli ranging 1–50. Phys. MathSciNet {\displaystyle T} Radial profiles of the scalar refractive index used for simulations of optical Schwarzschild black holes with impact parameters \(\hat{b}_\infty =\) a 2, b 3, c 4, and d 5. This yields, This solution has a number of noteworthy features. This results from the discretization of n(R). For 2 corresponding to the FDFD solutions in Fig. 13, 024004 (2010). 6; this is a significant percent change compared to profile b in Fig. ) Dedimensionalizing these parameters via \(\ell =M\hat{\ell }\) and \(\sigma =M\hat{\sigma }\) (note that the energy is already dimensionless, \(\hat{\varepsilon }=\varepsilon\)), null geodesics satisfy the geodesic equation52, Combining this equation with \({\left(\frac{{\rm{d}}\phi }{{\rm{d}}\hat{\sigma }}\right)}^{2}={\hat{\ell }}^{2}/{\rho }^{4}\) yields, We then make use of the spacetime impact parameter \(\hat{b}(\rho )=\rho \sin \beta\), where β is defined by the relation, Plugging this relation into Eq. Ye, X.-H. & Lin, Q. Gravitational lensing analyzed by the graded refractive index of a vacuum. Juan Ramón Muñoz de Nova, Katrine Golubkov, … Jeff Steinhauer, Sayanti Dasgupta, Ahmed Atteya & Pralay Kumar Karmakar, J. The benefits of building larger systems are discussed in the next section. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. {\displaystyle r\gg r_{\text{s}}} Science 308, 534–537 (2005). For a light ray incident on annulus (i + 1) (propagating in the region Ri ≤ R ≤ Ri−1), let the impact parameter be \({B}_{i}={R}_{i}\sin {\Phi }_{i}\), where Φi is the azimuthal angle at which the ray intersects the annulus at Ri. X 8, 011001 (2018). & Philbin, T. Geometry and light: the science of invisibility (Courier Corporation, 2010). S Phys. Instead, light begins to orbit at the photon sphere, R = 3M = 7.5 μm. $$\Delta\vec{r} = \vec{r}_1 - \vec{r}_0,$$ Express 18, 16646–16662 (2010). {\displaystyle (r_{\text{s}}/r^{3})c^{2}L} 2 Simulating these trajectories amounts to ray tracing, which we pursue in the following section. t Many recent works have focused on optical analogues to static, uncharged (Schwarzschild) black holes in an isotropic coordinate system. 4a, an extremal Reissner–Nordström black hole (\(\hat{a}=0,\rho_Q=1\)) is simulated, with FDFD results depicted in Fig. Article 109, 103104 (2011). [16] Synge's later derivation of the Szekeres-Kruskal metric solution,[20] which was motivated by a desire to avoid "using 'bad' [Schwarzschild] coordinates to obtain 'good' [Szekeres-Kruskal] coordinates," has been generally under-appreciated in the literature, but was adopted by Chandrasekhar in his black hole monograph. Data is available from the corresponding author upon request. 1 and 2 is \(n/\left\Vert \nabla n\right\Vert \sim 0.6 \, \upmu \mathrm{m}\), so \(\lambda \, < \, n/\left\Vert \nabla n\right\Vert\) is valid for the above FDFD simulations. Chen, H., Wu, B.-I., Zhang, B. We examined curved two dimensional surfaces to get an idea of the techniques used to determine curvature. {\displaystyle {\frac {r_{\text{s}}}{R}}} Even at the surface of the Earth, the corrections to Newtonian gravity are only one part in a billion. Divergent reflections around the photon sphere of a black hole, Observation of thermal Hawking radiation and its temperature in an analogue black hole, Static and stationary dark fluid universes: a gravitoelectromagnetic perspective, Acoustic stability of a self-gravitating cylinder leading to astrostructure formation, Quasinormal modes and shadow of noncommutative black hole, Schrödinger–Poisson systems under gradient fields, Surfaces away from horizons are not thermodynamic, http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Fernández-Núñez, I. Google Scholar. Throughout this paper we use Gaussian Planck units, with c = ℏ = G = 4πϵ0 = 1. L The results demonstrate that with a modest number of annuli, the approximate gradient-index systems adequately reproduce null geodesics and are robust to small variations in refractive index and impact parameter.
schwarzschild metric in cartesian coordinatesseidenhuhn geschlecht erkennen
For a spacelike path, you would use the $+$ under the square root and interpret the $s$ as the proper length separating the points. & Bulashenko, O. Anisotropic metamaterial as an analogue of a black hole. {\left|E\right|}^{2}\)); however, only the electric field amplitude is shown here for better visualization of both small and large amplitude features. Express 21, 19082–19090 (2013). ξ s It omits the spatial translations (three dimensions) and boosts (three dimensions). 4. At r = 0 the curvature becomes infinite, indicating the presence of a singularity. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Pires, D. G., Rocha, J. C. A. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. ^ T Specifically, we investigate the number of annuli needed to sufficiently mimic the true scalar-index profile and explore the impact of imperfect construction and experimental error on the deviation of the ray trajectory from the geodesic. This can be seen immediately by noting that initially counter-rotating geodesics (those with \(\hat{\ell }\) of opposite sign to \(\hat{a}\)) must turn around and become co-rotating before crossing into the ergosphere; such a reversal of the sign of \(\frac{{\rm{d}}\phi }{{\rm{d}}\rho }\) is not possible with a finite (and positive) scalar index. Science 312, 1777–1780 (2006). Lett. Regarding ds=0 being a path followed by massless particles such as light, if i search numerically for very small sequences of ds=0 steps from a starting point, will it end up being a geodesic path followed by light? Several optical Kerr–Newman black holes are also simulated, with profiles n(P) in Fig. B 83, 195424 (2011). but the transformation that converts these coordinates to Cartesian ones is singular. Phys. This makes total sense. Box 7.3aising and Lowering Indices in Cartesian Coordinates R 83 Box 7.4he Tensor Equation for Conservation of Charge T 84. . Leonhardt, U. It is important to note here that this geometry was chosen for simplicity in the finite-difference frequency-domain simulations of the next section, in which dimensions are constrained by the wavelength. Setting n = 1 at P → ∞ in Eq. First, we reiterate that Eq. We choose a specific trajectory with impact parameter \(\hat{b}_\infty =3\) to connect with the FDFD simulations of the previous section. 6b as a function of radius P = R/M. The minimum gradient scale length of the scalar-index profiles in Figs. By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. In table above, some shorthand has been introduced for brevity. Most trajectories follow the geodesic closely, within ΔΦ ≤ 2∘, for P > 3; however, within P < 3, ΔΦ grows rapidly. (14) and (23). Here, the optical black hole could be modeled completely to the horizon at Rh = 2.5 μm. Therefore, though the horizon is at Ph = 1, the system is modeled with innermost radius P = 1.4. Specifically, the behavior of light in a curved spacetime background described by metric gμν is reproduced in flat space within an impedance-matched bianisotropic medium with permittivity ϵij, permeability μij, and magnetoelectric coupling αi given by, where γij is the three-dimensional metric tensor of the real space coordinate system in which we construct the medium, onto which we map the spatial components gij. 2 53, this choice of identification between the spacetime geometry and the electromagnetic analogue, elaborated first in ref. Lett. & Hwang, E. Experimental modeling of cosmological inflation with metamaterials. It is possible for a particle to have a constant value of r between rs and 1.5rs, but only if some force acts to keep it there. For timelike paths, proper time is a common choice. This is the principle of general covariance. The scalar index for an optical Kerr–Newman black hole is again given by. This results because the impact parameter is nearly equal to that at which light becomes trapped, \(\hat{b}_\infty =3\sqrt{3}\approx 5.2\). The innermost modeled radius varies for each simulation, depending on whether n(P) diverges outside of the horizon. Synge, J. L. "Model universes with spherical symmetry." For ordinary stars and planets this is always the case. J. Opt. Thompson, R. T. & Frauendiener, J. Dielectric analog space-times. Kerr Metric in Cartesian Coordinates Ask Question Asked 2 years, 10 months ago Modified 2 years, 10 months ago Viewed 516 times 2 I have checked online and the Kerr metric never seems to be given in Cartesian coordinates (although there is a conversion factor from Cartesian to Boyer-Lindquist coordinates). The aim of this section is to find a global system of harmonic coordinates for the complete Schwarzschild model, which must be asymptotically Cartesian and such that the components of the metric are C1 at the boundary Σ : r = r0. The Schwarzschild metric describes the spacetime geometry of a static, uncharged black hole of mass M, and is given in dimensionless Schwarzschild coordinates \(\hat{s},\hat{t},\rho ,\theta ,\phi . 99, 063903 (2007). Correspondence to Analogue spacetimes1,2,14,15,16,17,18,19 use optical materials to implement coordinate transformations between a physical space and a virtual “electromagnetic space”, via the formal equivalence between Maxwell’s equations in curved spacetime and those in flat spacetime within a corresponding bianisotropic medium19,20,21,22,23. For future questions, you can refer to. A 380, 1–8 (2016). I was worried about taking absolute value before the square root to get rid of negative quantities, but this is standard procedure for computing ds, right? You can then press tab to accept, or type the whole thing out yourself. {\displaystyle R} The finite-difference frequency-domain solver used in this work is available at https://github.com/wsshin/maxwellfdfd. Article Here, we derive Eq. . The ray trajectories (Fig. ( However, as there is no analytic solution to the wave equation for the system under consideration, the pursuit of a more appropriate metric is left to future work. Box 5.2roof of the Metric Transformation Law P 59 Box 5.3 A 2D Example: . The Kerr–Newman metric describes the spacetime geometry surrounding a black hole of mass M, angular momentum per unit mass a = J/M, electric charge Q, and magnetic charge Qm. 5 for \(\hat{b}_\infty \in [0,5]\) and the number of annuli ranging 1–50. Phys. MathSciNet {\displaystyle T} Radial profiles of the scalar refractive index used for simulations of optical Schwarzschild black holes with impact parameters \(\hat{b}_\infty =\) a 2, b 3, c 4, and d 5. This yields, This solution has a number of noteworthy features. This results from the discretization of n(R). For 2 corresponding to the FDFD solutions in Fig. 13, 024004 (2010). 6; this is a significant percent change compared to profile b in Fig. ) Dedimensionalizing these parameters via \(\ell =M\hat{\ell }\) and \(\sigma =M\hat{\sigma }\) (note that the energy is already dimensionless, \(\hat{\varepsilon }=\varepsilon\)), null geodesics satisfy the geodesic equation52, Combining this equation with \({\left(\frac{{\rm{d}}\phi }{{\rm{d}}\hat{\sigma }}\right)}^{2}={\hat{\ell }}^{2}/{\rho }^{4}\) yields, We then make use of the spacetime impact parameter \(\hat{b}(\rho )=\rho \sin \beta\), where β is defined by the relation, Plugging this relation into Eq. Ye, X.-H. & Lin, Q. Gravitational lensing analyzed by the graded refractive index of a vacuum. Juan Ramón Muñoz de Nova, Katrine Golubkov, … Jeff Steinhauer, Sayanti Dasgupta, Ahmed Atteya & Pralay Kumar Karmakar, J. The benefits of building larger systems are discussed in the next section. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. {\displaystyle r\gg r_{\text{s}}} Science 308, 534–537 (2005). For a light ray incident on annulus (i + 1) (propagating in the region Ri ≤ R ≤ Ri−1), let the impact parameter be \({B}_{i}={R}_{i}\sin {\Phi }_{i}\), where Φi is the azimuthal angle at which the ray intersects the annulus at Ri. X 8, 011001 (2018). & Philbin, T. Geometry and light: the science of invisibility (Courier Corporation, 2010). S Phys. Instead, light begins to orbit at the photon sphere, R = 3M = 7.5 μm. $$\Delta\vec{r} = \vec{r}_1 - \vec{r}_0,$$ Express 18, 16646–16662 (2010). {\displaystyle (r_{\text{s}}/r^{3})c^{2}L} 2 Simulating these trajectories amounts to ray tracing, which we pursue in the following section. t Many recent works have focused on optical analogues to static, uncharged (Schwarzschild) black holes in an isotropic coordinate system. 4a, an extremal Reissner–Nordström black hole (\(\hat{a}=0,\rho_Q=1\)) is simulated, with FDFD results depicted in Fig. Article 109, 103104 (2011). [16] Synge's later derivation of the Szekeres-Kruskal metric solution,[20] which was motivated by a desire to avoid "using 'bad' [Schwarzschild] coordinates to obtain 'good' [Szekeres-Kruskal] coordinates," has been generally under-appreciated in the literature, but was adopted by Chandrasekhar in his black hole monograph. Data is available from the corresponding author upon request. 1 and 2 is \(n/\left\Vert \nabla n\right\Vert \sim 0.6 \, \upmu \mathrm{m}\), so \(\lambda \, < \, n/\left\Vert \nabla n\right\Vert\) is valid for the above FDFD simulations. Chen, H., Wu, B.-I., Zhang, B. We examined curved two dimensional surfaces to get an idea of the techniques used to determine curvature. {\displaystyle {\frac {r_{\text{s}}}{R}}} Even at the surface of the Earth, the corrections to Newtonian gravity are only one part in a billion. Divergent reflections around the photon sphere of a black hole, Observation of thermal Hawking radiation and its temperature in an analogue black hole, Static and stationary dark fluid universes: a gravitoelectromagnetic perspective, Acoustic stability of a self-gravitating cylinder leading to astrostructure formation, Quasinormal modes and shadow of noncommutative black hole, Schrödinger–Poisson systems under gradient fields, Surfaces away from horizons are not thermodynamic, http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Fernández-Núñez, I. Google Scholar. Throughout this paper we use Gaussian Planck units, with c = ℏ = G = 4πϵ0 = 1. L The results demonstrate that with a modest number of annuli, the approximate gradient-index systems adequately reproduce null geodesics and are robust to small variations in refractive index and impact parameter. Underground Of Berlin Staffel 2,
Articles S
